logo

91 pages 3 hours read

Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1818

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 9-12Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 9 Summary

Frankenstein laments that Justine is dead while he lives and that he “had begun life with benevolent intentions” yet has “committed deeds of mischief beyond description” (74). His health suffers, and he shuns all company. He and his family go to their house in the town of Belrive, and Frankenstein wishes he could drown in the lake. He refrains from suicide only to spare Elizabeth more grief.

Frankenstein continues to fear for his grieving family’s safety and is furious with the creature. He thinks about Elizabeth, who is “no longer that happy creature” who frolicked with him by the lake when they were children (76). Her view of humankind has changed; now, she sees men “as monsters thirsting for each other’s blood” (76). Frankenstein believes he is “the true murderer” (77), and nothing cheers him.

Seeking refuge, Frankenstein embarks on a journey to the village of Chamounix. He finds the mountains unchanged despite his own misery. He sees in the mountain and waterfalls “a power mighty as Omnipotence” (78), and he decides not to bow to any force but the God who made them. He observes Mount Blanc in the distance and recalls climbing as a child and “the light-hearted gaiety of boyhood” (79). He feels comforted by “maternal Nature” but then remembers his grief and falls to the grass. He arrives in Chamounix and is grateful to fall into the “oblivion” of sleep (79).

Chapter 10 Summary

The next day, Frankenstein wanders through the valley, and the mountains’ magnificence calms him. The next morning, however, his “dark melancholy” returns when he sees that rain is “pouring in torrents” (80). He decides to climb the Montanvert summit despite the rain. He reaches the top and looks out at the “awful majesty” of Mont Blanc. He then sees a figure—the creature—approaching him with “superhuman speed.” Frankenstein waits, planning to engage in “mortal combat.” As the creature grows closer, Frankenstein sees that his face shows “disdain and malignity.” The creature’s “unearthly ugliness” makes looking at him nearly impossible.

Frankenstein asks the creature how he “dare approach” him and cries that he wishes killing the creature would bring back William and Justine. The creature says he “expected this reception” (83). He chastises Frankenstein for hating his own creation and for playing with life by creating him and then threatening to kill him. He then tells Frankenstein that if Frankenstein does his “duty” toward him, he will do his duty to humanity by leaving it “at peace.” If Frankenstein refuses, the creature will kill his friends and family.

When Frankenstein again rejects him, the creature begs him to “perform [his] part, the which [he] owes” as his creator (84). He is devastated that he alone is “irrevocably excluded” from the “bliss” he sees in the world. Once “benevolent and good” (84), he is only “a fiend” because of his “misery” (84). Though his soul once “glowed with love and humanity” (84), his loneliness has made him a monster. He expects to be able to defend himself just as the guilty are according to “human laws.” He suggests Frankenstein is a hypocrite.

Frankenstein rejects him a third time, and the creature warns him that whether he lives “a harmless life” or “become[s] the scourge” of humanity is in Frankenstein’s hands (85). He hopes Frankenstein will follow him to a hut on the mountain so he can hear the creature’s story. Frankenstein follows him across the ice, deciding to listen. As rain descends, they enter the hut.

Chapter 11 Summary

Now told from the creature’s first-person perspective, the novel relates how he gained consciousness.

He remembers his senses awakening and the gradual awareness of light. He wanders into the forest and rests and then eats berries and drinks from the brook. He is alone and cold—despite stealing some clothes from Frankenstein, including a cloak—and he weeps, though the sight of the moon comforts him. Several days pass. He hears birds chirping and tries to imitate their sounds, but he is horrified by the “uncouth and inarticulate sounds” of his own voice (88).

One day, he sees an abandoned fire; he puts his hand in and pulls it out in pain. By studying the fire, he discovers how to make his own. He is pleased that the fire provides both heat and light. He also cooks some berries. He moves through the forest and finds a hut. Upon entering, a man screams and flees.

After resting, the creature approaches a village. He enters a house, where people scream and faint. Others attack and throw stones at him. He escapes to a hovel that is attached to a cottage, but mindful of his experiences thus far, he does not enter the cottage. The hovel allows him escape “the inclemency of the season,” as well as “the barbarity of man” (91).

In the morning, having taken a loaf of bread and a cup for water, he explores the surroundings. He looks inside the cottage through a chink in the wall, watching as a simply dressed girl and a young man exchange sorrowful looks and tend to their work.

An old man sits in the corner. The girl takes him a musical instrument. Even the creature, who “had never held aught beautiful before” (93), is moved by the music. The young man soon returns, carrying chopped wood with which they refuel the fire. The creature admires the cottagers’ beauty and notices that the young man appears sad. He feels great “pleasure” in watching them, though he cannot comprehend their actions. He watches as the young man reads aloud but is ignorant as to what he is saying.

Chapter 12 Summary

The creature is struck by the cottagers’ gentleness. He wants to approach them but, remembering how he was attacked, decides not to. The next day, the young man and the girl work in the house and in the yard. The creature notices how much love they lavish on the old man, who is blind. He also notices that they are unhappy and wonders why.

As time goes on, he realizes they are poor and have inadequate supplies of food. Despite their own hunger, the young man and the girl give the old man their shares. This sacrifice touches creature, who decides he will no longer take from their food supply. He also chops wood for them at night and is delighted when this act brings them joy. The creature realizes that the sounds they utter to each other are words and seeks to learn the language. He learns their words by degrees. He now knows that the girl is Agatha and that the young man, her brother, is Felix.

Throughout the winter, the creature watches the cottagers and grows to care for them. The cottagers perform acts of kindness for each other, and the creature continues to perform anonymous kind tasks for them. Felix frequently reads to his father. Eventually, understanding that Felix is reading words, the creature decides to learn to read. He hopes that learning their language will enable him “to make them overlook the deformity of [his] figure” (98).

The creature contrasts the cottagers’ beauty with his own appearance. He looks at his reflection in the water and is “unable to believe that it [is] indeed [he] who [is] reflected in the mirror” (98). He feels “the bitterest sensations of despondence and mortification” (99).

Spring comes, and the creature continues performing tasks for the family, who are grateful to the “invisible hand” that helps them. Though he now considers himself a “foolish wretch” (99) for thinking so, the creature believes he might be able to “restore happiness to these deserving people” (99). He imagines meeting with them and earning their affection with his “gentle demeanour and conciliating words” (100). He is happy that the earth comes alive with spring. His “spirits [are] elevated by the enchanting appearance of nature” (100), and he forgets his past disappointments.

Chapters 9-12 Analysis

Though the creature initially remains unseen after his awakening, his presence is felt in the deaths he supposedly caused. When the creature finally appears in Chapter 10, he is not at all what Frankenstein has suggested. His first words—that he “expected this reception” (83)—are not the language of a “monster.” Rather, they show him to be intelligent and thoughtful. The conversation that takes place upon the creature’s reintroduction is the first sign that the creature is not the evil being Frankenstein believes he is, raising the question of The Nature of Humanity.

Elements of the creature’s story indicate he is more human than monster. The fright he feels upon hearing his bestial voice suggests human aesthetic preferences. His instinctive understanding of love and beauty is evident because he is moved by music even though he “had never held aught beautiful before” (93). He also has an innate sense of morality; he stops stealing food when he realizes the cottagers are poor and performs anonymous charity by cutting their firewood. The creature’s first days are reminiscent of those of a human child. He learns fire is hot by putting his hand in it and being burned. His weeping in the forest because of the cold and loneliness evokes the distress of an abandoned child. Even his gradual learning of language mirrors the life of a human child.

The creature is childlike not only in his learning of nature and language but also in his gradual awakening to the cruelty of man. At first, the creature hopes the cottagers can accept him as a friend once they see how gentle he is. However, his hope and goodness dissipate with the rejection he faces. Despite his inherent morality and his belief in the morality of others, the creature is feared and tormented by humans. When he enters a hut, the occupant screams and runs away from him; when he later enters a house, villagers attack him with stones. Being driven from humans’ homes, denied the comforts of love, and forced to live in a crude hovel symbolize the creature’s subhuman status in society’s eyes. This again raises the question of Nature Versus Nurture, as the creature claims that he is only “a fiend” because he has been “irrevocably excluded.” He becomes what people believe him to be, which suggests that he could live a peaceful, moral existence. However, the misery he conveys to Frankenstein foreshadows that his hopes for acceptance from the cottagers will be crushed, reinforcing the lessons of humankind’s barbarity.

Both Frankenstein and the creature are comforted by nature, developing the theme of Nature as a Miraculous, Healing Force. Frankenstein, after the devastation of William’s death, is “tempted to plunge into the silent lake, that the waters might close over [him] and [his] calamities forever” (75). His yearning to die completely immersed in the outdoors shows his desire to be reclaimed by nature, from which he is alienated. On his journey shortly afterward, he looks at the mountains and rivers and sees in them a godlike power—a feeling that makes him cease “to fear or to bend before any being less almighty” than that which created these splendors (78). That nature is a “maternal” force with which he feels safe further underscores the proper hierarchy, which Frankenstein has flouted by taking on the powers of creation himself.

Similarly, the creature initially weeps when he finds himself alone in the forest, but he soon experiences a great “sensation of pleasure” upon observing the moon (88). Later, when spring arrives, the creature witnesses the rebirth of the trees and the chirping of birds, and his “spirits [are] elevated by the enchanting appearance of nature” (100). Frankenstein and the creature’s similar feelings about nature not only show the creature’s humanity but also connect them to each other. As the novel progresses, their character arcs further intertwine and parallel one another.

In keeping with their interest in nature, these chapters showcase Shelley’s continued use of pathetic fallacy, as when nature reflects the creature’s loneliness. The “dreary glaciers” that are the creature’s “refuge” reflect the fact that he is “miserably alone.” He tells Frankenstein that in the first days of his existence, snowfall made the landscape “disconsolate”—a word that speaks to his own emptiness

Finally, these chapters introduce the motif of God and Adam. The creature tells Frankenstein that while he should be like Frankenstein’s Adam—a beloved creation made in Frankenstein’s own image—he is instead “the fallen angel” Satan (84), whom God cast into Hell. If the creature is a fallen angel, however, Frankenstein has failed in The Duty of a Creator. The creature chastises Frankenstein for creating him only to try to kill him, asking, “How dare you sport thus with life?” (83). This underscores the overarching theme of The Dangers of Knowledge, as the creature implies that Frankenstein has meddled with divine powers. In this sense, it is Frankenstein, not the creature, who embodies Adam and Satan, as later references to the motif make clear.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 91 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools