59 pages • 1 hour read
Miller describes her hometown of Palo Alto, California, painting a picture of an idyllic neighborhood where “everybody has degrees and everybody recycles” (29). She details her life before the sexual assault working at a start-up. This was Miller’s first job out of college, and she had been working there for six months. Now, Miller struggles to return to her normal life and discovers bruises across her hands. She begins riding her bicycle late at night, which worries her father.
Miller’s sister Tiffany returns to the police station to identify the aggressive man from the fraternity party. The man she identifies is Miller’s assailant. Ten days pass before Miller reads in the newspaper that a Stanford athlete named Brock Turner was arrested for raping an unconscious woman. She learns about the graphic details of her own rape from the newspaper. She answers a barrage of calls from Deputy District Attorney Alaleh, from a Stanford representative, from Detective Kim, and from her advocate from the YWCA. Tiffany calls and tells her that her own name and the name of her friend Julia have been leaked. Miller realizes that reporters must have gained access to transcripts from the hospital and “sifted through them, using [her] words to construct their own narrative for the public to pore over” (36).
Miller reads about her assailant, Brock Turner, whom articles portray as a gifted swimmer. They only mention her in the graphic details of the scene noted by the arriving officer, who describes her unconscious and partially naked body. She reads a negative comment and decides to further detach from the situation by referring to the part of herself that was assaulted as Emily Doe.
Miller transitions into an examination of her hometown of Palo Alto and the “layer below the sun and smiles” of “pressure, not in a kettle screaming sort of way, more like a simmering” (37-38). In her high school, the expectations were that “you had to make sense, to stay aligned with the mass that progressed so smoothly upward” (38). This need to keep up led students to make “mental health […] last on [their] list” (38). During Miller’s junior year of high school, four students committed suicide within six months. Miller depicts the effect these circumstances had on the student body: “[Y]ou were either treated as an extreme case on the verge of death, or you were expected to carry on; nothing in between. So we settled for perpetual numbness” (39). The suicides continued after Miller’s graduation, totaling 10. These experiences led Miller to adopt the same method of survival following her sexual assault by detaching from her emotions.
Miller returns home that evening and decides to disclose her sexual assault to her parents. It is only after telling her parents that Miller unleashes the full torrent of her emotions and feels like “[her] body could finally soften, exhale” (44). The next day, Miller reads articles that detail Turner’s defense of his actions and his explanation that Miller had consented. She begins to realize how she will be blamed for her assault. She obsessively reads the comments that defend her assailant’s violent actions and blame her for the assault: “[H]e was the one who lost everything. I was just the nobody it happened to” (48). Unable to defend herself openly, Miller lashes out at those around her.
Miller analyzes the unique ways in which society blames rape victims for the actions of their assailants, questioning victims about defending themselves while excusing male assailants on the grounds they “simply could not help themselves” (50). Miller calls out the hypocrisy of the double standards society places on women, who are plagued by “countless guidelines […] to follow: cover your drink, stick close to others, don’t wear short skirts” (50). She discusses the lawlessness of college campuses where “[S]ituations are softened, stripped of severity and any kind of seriousness, any real punishment” (51).
Overwhelmed, Miller leaves work on Friday and calls a hotline number from a pamphlet given to her in the hospital. She confesses that she is victim of the Stanford rape and becomes frustrated at the platitudes repeated to her. She feels alone and unsupported in learning “how to hold all this hostility, this wrecking sadness” (52).
Chapter 2 recounts Miller’s transformation in the aftermath of her sexual assault. Physically, she notices bruises emerging from the attack. These serve as visible representations of the trauma she has endured. Mentally, she finds herself more and more distracted as she attempts to store away any memories or thoughts of the attack. She uses the image of the jar as a symbol of this detachment and dissociation, which cause her to become increasingly overwhelmed: “I was full of these sealed jars, no room to sit or walk or breathe” (32). She takes up riding her bike alone at night to run away from her thoughts and emotions and to distract herself.
Miller learns about the graphic details of her rape from the newspaper. The fact that she only finds clarity about what happened to her in this highly public forum demonstrates how survivors are not centered in the investigation process and the confusion left in the wake of their assaults. She illustrates the overwhelming nature of this process when she relays the first phone conversation she has with Deputy District Attorney Alaleh. Here, Miller uses a lack of punctuation and run-on sentences to capture the deluge of details and emotions that engulf her in this moment. The reader absorbs the information in the way that Miller absorbed the information and is left swamped and exhausted in the process.
This relentless outpouring of information characterizes the days that follow Miller’s assault. She is contacted repeatedly and warned of investigators and reporters who may seek to engage with her and her family. Miller describes this as “being hunted” (35). By comparing this to a hunt, Miller conveys the invasive nature of these contacts that do not center her recovery as a victim but seek to parse the details of the case for public scrutiny. Miller thus depicts the ways in which survivors are silenced and violated beyond the assault itself. She realizes that reporters might have gained access to her transcripts from the rape clinic in the vulnerable hours after her assault. She poses the following rhetorical question: “If words spoken softly at a rape clinic were projected over a megaphone, where was it safe for me to speak?” (36). Miller implies that, for survivors, the answer is nowhere. By posing this question, Miller calls into question the lack of a safe and protected platform for survivors to speak from.
As a result of this silencing, Miller decides to dissociate. She refers to the version of herself that survived a sexual assault as Emily Doe. To cope with the raw reality of her assault, Miller decides that “the body being publicly taken apart did not belong to [her]” (37). This is a choice made for self-preservation and survival. Miller takes time to explore where she learned this coping mechanism by sharing her experiences growing up in the high-pressure environment of Palo Alto. Miller describes how she learned to separate awful circumstances from daily life in high school in response to the prevalence of suicide in the community. Miller forges a direct connection between her experiences as a witness to her community’s struggles with mental health and the detachment she adopts in the wake of her sexual assault. She states, “[W]hatever alarms rose in my body were silenced, the horror made distant. My eyes became wet, I would cry in private, but I knew I would do what I had always done” (41). As Miller’s story progresses, she grapples with this coping mechanism and its implications for her mental health.
Through her examination of the public portrayal of her assault, Miller studies the ways in which society enforces double standards for female survivors and male assailants. After reading Turner’s defense of consent, Miller realizes that “He’d force moans in [her] mouth, assign lecherous behavior, to shift the blame onto [her]” (46). She documents the dehumanization she continues to face as a survivor: “[H]e’d seen me as a body, but would attempt to destroy me as a person” (46). She examines not only the ways in which Turner’s defense attempts to villainize her but also the ways in which the public blames women for their own sexual assaults, including the higher standard placed on women in regard to drinking alcohol: “[B]eing drunk and raped seemed to call for condemnation. People were confounded that I had failed to protect myself” (47). Meanwhile, news coverage laments Turner’s lost potential as a gifted swimmer.
Miller calls out the hypocrisy of these double standards that place the burden of safety on women while excusing the violent choices made by men. She proclaims that “[B]oys are people, they have minds, live in a society with laws. Groping others was not a natural reflex, biologically built in. It was a cognitive action they were capable of controlling” (50). In her feminist analysis of society’s unequal treatment of female survivors, Miller exposes how society tolerates and centers men by making “their behavior […] the constant, while [women] [are] the variable expected to change” (50). The effect this treatment has on female survivors is not confronted. This leaves survivors struggling to cope with feelings of low self-worth and aggravated self-blame.
At the chapter’s conclusion, a desperate and distraught Miller reaches out to the hotline number the Stanford representative provided to her in passing in her hospital room. She is not provided any real support and is left alone to navigate the trauma that increasingly threatens to disrupt her daily life. This moment embodies the negligence of Stanford University throughout Miller’s account. She states that the phone call she receives in the moments after the assault is made public “would be the first and last time [she]’d hear from Stanford for almost two years” (34). Miller does not shy away from confronting colleges’ negligence in confronting sexual assault on campuses and providing support centered on survivors.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: