logo

47 pages 1 hour read

Midnight Rising

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2011

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 1, Chapters 3-6Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1, Chapter 3 Summary: “A Warlike Spirit”

Chapter 3 captures a pivotal period in Brown’s life during the 1840s and 1850s, a time marked by personal challenges and increasing involvement in the abolitionist movement. As Brown grappled with bankruptcy and depression, his ideological convictions deepened, leading him toward a path of direct action against enslavement.

The chapter begins with an anecdote about Brown undergoing a phrenological examination by Orson Fowler, in which the latter accurately identified Brown’s strong self-assuredness, leadership tendencies, and financial imprudence. Later Brown embarked on a wool trading venture that ultimately failed due to market fluctuations and Brown’s stubborn business strategies.

Amid these personal and financial struggles, Brown’s abolitionist spirit was stoked by the political and social turmoil of the time, particularly by the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 and the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854. These acts intensified the national debate over enslavement and propelled Brown toward more radical measures. His meeting with Frederick Douglass in 1847-48 and his plans to establish a guerrilla base in the Allegheny Mountains for the liberation of enslaved people illustrate the evolution of his strategy from peaceful resistance to armed insurrection.

Gerrit Smith, a wealthy abolitionist and Brown’s eventual benefactor, persuaded him to move to North Elba, New York, to help Black pioneers farm. Meanwhile, the crisis over enslavement deepened, particularly with the passage of the Kansas-Nebraska Act, which effectively nullified the Missouri Compromise and reignited the conflict between pro-enslavement and anti-enslavement forces.

As the situation in Kansas deteriorated, with pro-enslavement forces from Missouri (dubbed “Border Ruffians”) exerting violent pressure on the territory, Brown’s sons, who had moved to Kansas, found themselves amid growing tensions and appealed to their father for support and arms.

Brown’s eventual decision to head to Kansas in 1855, despite his initial hesitations and commitments in New York, marked a decisive turn in his life. His actions reflected a growing determination to confront enslavement head-on. The chapter closes with Brown preparing to leave for Kansas, armed with funds, weapons, and a “warlike spirit,” driven by a strong belief in the moral righteousness of his cause and a willingness to engage in armed conflict to end enslavement.

Part 1, Chapter 4 Summary: “First Blood”

In Chapter 4 the narrative recounts Brown’s arrival in Kansas during a period of escalating tension and violence between pro-enslavement and anti-enslavement settlers. Initially drawn by his sons’ descriptions of the land’s beauty and potential, Brown found a reality marked by sickness, harsh weather, and looming conflict upon his arrival in October 1855. Despite these challenges, Brown was determined to fight against enslavement, believing it to be his divine mission.

The chapter outlines the extreme laws enacted by the pro-enslavement legislature in Kansas, which criminalized anti-enslavement expression and actions, prompting Brown to arm himself and his followers. Brown’s first opportunity for armed conflict arose shortly after his arrival but resulted in no engagement with pro-enslavement forces. However, Brown’s resolve hardened, and by spring 1856, Kansas was a powder keg of tension, with Brown and his family at the heart of the free-state resistance.

The Pottawatomie Massacre in May 1856 is detailed as a brutal response to pro-enslavement aggression, where Brown and his group killed five pro-enslavement settlers in a night of violence. This act, while aiming to deter pro-enslavement forces, instead intensified the conflict in Kansas, leading to a period known as “Bleeding Kansas.” Brown’s actions at Pottawatomie and subsequent engagements, including the Battle of Black Jack and the defense of Osawatomie, cemented his reputation as a fearless and committed abolitionist leader, albeit at great personal and familial cost.

Part 1, Chapter 5 Summary: “Secret Service”

Chapter 5 charts Brown’s transition from a combative figure in Kansas to a strategic planner on a national stage. After a grueling year of guerrilla warfare in Kansas, which solidified his reputation as a fierce abolitionist, Brown, plagued by illness and financial woes, departed for the East to muster support for a more audacious undertaking against enslavement.

Upon reaching Ohio, Brown shifted his focus from battling pro-enslavement forces in Kansas to preparing for a significant strike against enslavement in the Southern states, specifically Virginia. His journey eastward involved strategic stops to gather resources and allies. In Massachusetts, he connected with influential abolitionists, including Franklin Sanborn, who became a key ally in navigating the abolitionist networks of New England. Sanborn introduced Brown to the elite circles of the anti-enslavement movement, helping him gain the financial and logistical support necessary for his plans.

Brown’s speaking engagements and private meetings with influential abolitionists and activists, such as Frederick Douglass, reflect his shift toward a more covert and grandiose strategy. He meticulously planned the logistics of his envisioned uprising, drafting a constitution for a revolutionary state and selecting Harpers Ferry, Virginia, as the focal point for his attack because seizing a federal armory could help arm the rebellion he hoped to initiate.

The formation of the Secret Six, a group of wealthy and influential abolitionists, was a critical juncture in Brown’s campaign, providing him with the financial backing and moral support needed for his venture. Despite reservations about the feasibility and morality of his plan, the Secret Six were compelled by Brown’s unwavering commitment and the chance to strike a significant blow against the institution of enslavement.

As Brown prepared to return to the battlefield, now with a clear target in Virginia, the narrative highlights the complexities of his character and mission, including his unwavering belief in divine providence, his willingness to engage in violent rebellion, and his ability to inspire and mobilize a dedicated group of followers. The chapter underscores the tension between Brown’s radical methods and the broader abolitionist movement.

Part 1, Chapter 6 Summary: “This Spark of Fire”

Chapter 6 follows Brown’s intricate planning and mobilization efforts for his attack on Harpers Ferry. In April 1858, after scouting Canada as a potential rallying point for his mission, Brown reconvened with his recruits in Iowa. Despite the small size of his group, he remained determined to move forward, orchestrating a secret convention in Chatham, Canada, to draft a “Provisional Constitution” for a new society. The constitution articulated a vision for a society free from enslavement and outlined the structure of its government, with Brown as the commander-in-chief.

The convention, attended by Black delegates and a few white delegates, including Brown, culminated in the adoption of this constitution. However, enthusiasm for immediate action was tempered by practical considerations, and key positions within this provisional government remained unfilled.

Despite this, Brown’s mission in Missouri to free enslaved people and his audacious journey to bring them to freedom in Canada reinvigorated his cause, drawing admiration and renewed support from the Secret Six, a group of influential abolitionist backers. The book underscores Brown’s capacity for leadership and his symbolic role as a modern-day Moses, leading the oppressed to freedom. Yet, it also reveals the complexities of his character and the divergent perceptions of his mental state among those close to him.

As Brown prepared for the final phase of his mission, he encountered logistical and financial hurdles, including a disgruntled associate threatening to expose the plan, which forced Brown to temporarily postpone the Harpers Ferry attack. This setback drove Brown back to Kansas, where he engaged in further acts of resistance against enslavement but remained focused on his goal.

The chapter concludes with Brown’s return to the East to secure the final elements needed for the Harpers Ferry raid, including the completion of the pikes initially ordered for use in Kansas. His visit to his family in North Elba and the subsequent journey to Harpers Ferry, under the alias “I. Smith,” mark the final preparations for the attack.

Part 1, Chapters 3-6 Analysis

Horwitz’s portrayal of Brown in these chapters reinforces The Complex Legacy of John Brown. Brown emerges as an individual whose life journey embodies the tumultuous prelude to the Civil War. The narrative details Brown’s early adversities and moral upbringing, underscoring his unyielding opposition to enslavement. In his evolution from an ideologically driven abolitionist to the orchestrator of armed insurrection, Brown personifies the contentious divide over enslavement in America. Horwitz further explores Brown’s legacy through quotes and detailed historical accounts, such as the phrenological assessment by Orson Fowler and Brown’s contemplative acknowledgment of the Pottawatomie Massacre. This rhetorical choice provides insight into the intricate blend of moral conviction and tactical militancy that defined Brown’s crusade.

Horwitz captures Brown’s leadership qualities with a quote from Orson Fowler’s phrenological reading: “You have a pretty good opinion of yourself—would rather lead than be led” (45). Though it’s important to approach Fowler’s assessment with a grain of salt, given the dubious (and racist) foundation of phrenology, this observation offers a glimpse of how Brown was perceived by his contemporaries. Brown’s self-assuredness and his predisposition for leadership, even seen through the lens of a now-discredited practice, highlight the man’s deep-seated moral convictions and foreshadow his unwavering dedication to the abolitionist cause.

Horwitz uses Brown’s words to his son Jason about the Pottawatomie Massacre (“I did not do it, but I approved it” (69)) to elucidate The Complex Legacy of John Brown. Brown’s terse statement underlines the moral ambiguity and the ethical complexity surrounding violent acts committed in the name of justice. This statement encapsulates the conflict between Brown’s avowed Christian beliefs and his militant tactics.

Horwitz threads the theme of The United States on the Brink of Civil War through his recounting of Brown’s actions and the societal divisions they inflamed. The narrative charts Brown’s personal transformation from a “failed businessman” to “Captain Brown,” a progression that reflects not only Brown’s personal sacrifices but also the growing polarization and heightened tensions of American society at this time. The detailed exploration of Brown’s return to Kansas and his engagements with influential abolitionists and activists underscores the societal divisions and the looming specter of civil war.

Harpers Ferry’s Impact on American History emerges as a critical focal point in Horwitz’s account. He depicts the raid on Harpers Ferry not simply as an act of insurrection but also as a catalyst that exposed the deep-rooted fissures within American society over enslavement. Brown’s involved planning, the recruitment of allies, and the strategic execution of the raid illustrate his impact on the national consciousness and the abolitionist movement. Horwitz enriches his exploration of this theme through his description of Brown’s interactions with key figures and the formation of the Secret Six. These sections emphasize the strategic depth and ideological fervor that fueled the raid. Horwitz captures Brown’s resolve when he asserts, “God sees it […] I will die fighting for this cause” (75). This declaration illustrates not only Brown’s unwavering dedication to the abolitionist cause but also his belief that his mission was divinely approved. The quote underscores Brown’s actions at Harpers Ferry as a moment in American history where armed conflict was seen by some as necessary to challenge the institution of enslavement, presaging the violent conflict of the Civil War.

Horwitz employs a variety of literary devices and strategies—imagery, symbolism, foreshadowing, metaphor, and characterization—to breathe life into the narrative of Brown’s crusade. The description of Kansas as both a “pioneer paradise” and a harsh, unforgiving landscape not only sets the scene but also symbolizes the tumultuous journey Brown and his followers would endure. Through foreshadowing, Horwitz hints at the clash between Brown’s fervor and the pro-enslavement forces, characterizing the pre-Civil War era as a time marked by violent confrontations and simmering polarizations. Through Horwitz’s use of literary devices, Brown emerges not only as a historical figure but also as a complex individual who embodies the moral dilemmas and ideological battles of his time.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 47 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools