51 pages • 1 hour read
As the debate around violence intensified, Williams became an increasingly well-known figure, especially among the younger generation, who largely “regard[ed] non-violence […] as a tactical position of uncertain promise” (262).
In July of 1961, a series of fires broke out in businesses in Monroe. Authorities suspected Williams of arson but couldn’t find proof; regardless, the fires stirred panic among Monroe’s white residents. The SNCC called for a group of Freedom Riders to travel to Monroe in support of Williams. A group of 17 riders arrived on August 17th and were welcomed into the Williams home. The stated mission of their trip was to reconcile opponents and supporters of the NAACP. Visiting activists joined with the local community to create the Monroe Nonviolent Action Committee, which launched a picketing campaign outside of government buildings across Monroe. Though all participants agreed to maintain a strict doctrine of nonviolence, this resolve was challenged by counterdemonstrators who yelled obscenities and brandish weapons.
The situation came to a head on a Sunday when a 1,000-strong mob ambushed the Monroe Nonviolent Action Committee in downtown Monroe. When the chaos cleared, Monroe police arrested injured protestors on charges of inciting a riot. The protestors, largely Black men, were denied medical care, and some were beaten further by other inmates.
Racial hysteria swept through Monroe; “white folks were trying to kill the blacks and the blacks were [trying to kill] the whites” (275). The KKK sent motorcades out, firing shots into the homes of activists and their allies. Seeking protection, much of Monroe’s Black population gathered in Newtown near the Williams home, bracing for a perilous night. Williams set up a defensive barricade of armed men around Newtown.
Around 6 pm, a car carrying a white couple named Charles Bruce and Mabel Stegall accidentally turned into Newtown, bypassing the barricade. The angry crowd around Williams’s house pulled them from their vehicle and several people shouted for them to be killed. Williams calmed the crowd, insisting that no violence against the Stegalls would be allowed. He invited them inside and sheltered them briefly before sending them safely back on the road.
Williams realized that the situation would not de-escalate on its own, and Tyson notes that he “recognized the limits of armed struggle under the circumstances that prevailed in the Jim Crow South” (281). That night, Williams gathered his family and several firearms and quietly drove northward out of Monroe. As Tyson says, Williams’s allies in the SWP and the Fair Play for Cuba Committee “meshed into a modern-day Underground Railroad for him and his family” (283), transporting the Williams’s to the airport, where they boarded a flight for Cuba. While Williams was in hiding, the FBI issued a warrant for his arrest on kidnapping charges relating to the encounter with the Stegalls.
Williams remained in Havana, Cuba for four years, under the protection of Castro’s forces. Castro funded the creation of his radio program, “Radio Free Dixie,” which broadcasted a mixture of new jazz music, news about the Black liberation movement, and Williams’s own “fiery invective against white supremacy” (285).
The text’s conclusion opens with a quotation from an FBI report, noting the existence of Radio Free Dixie, a program “calling upon the oppressed Negroes to rise and free themselves” (287). Williams wanted Radio Free Dixie to be a voice for the voiceless in the South. In 1962, he gave a series of interviews to a white leftist named Marc Schliefer, detailing his time in the South. Together, they compiled the transcripts into a book called Negroes with Guns, which “became one of the classic documents of the black freedom struggle” (289). Williams also revived The Crusader from Havana, expanding the reach of his rhetoric stateside.
In the United States, the Black Power movement was taking shape. Among the young radicals who led it, Williams was a major source of inspiration. He was named president-in-exile of the Revolutionary Action Movement and the Republic of New Africa, two major Black nationalist groups. In 1966, Huey P. Newton and Bobby Searle founded the Black Panther Party for Self-Defense; Newton later cited Negroes with Guns as a major influence.
Throughout his exile, Williams longed to return to the South. After eight years abroad, he returned to the United States, where he was arrested on federal kidnapping charges but released on bond. All charges were dropped several years later.
Though many expected him to step into a leadership position in the Black Power movement, Williams expressed some disagreements with the modern Black Power philosophy; for example, he opposed racial separatism. Months after returning to America, he retired from the Revolutionary Action Movement and the Republic of New Africa. Seeking safety and peace, Williams moved his family to the small town of Baldwin, Michigan. His son John Williams noted that in a world where most prominent Black leaders were liable to end up dead, “my dad chose to live” (74). Williams lived out the rest of his years in Baldwin as a speaker and community activist before his death in 1996. The text closes by urging historians to “reexamine the relationship between civil rights and Black Power” (307), warning that a sanitized history of the movement threatens to “[blur] the racial dilemmas that follow us into the twenty-first century” (307).
In this section of the text, Tyson offers his final thoughts on the linkages between Williams’s philosophy of violence and the Black Power movement. By the early 1960s, Williams had long been characterized by enemies as an agitator and a troublemaker, but he had also gathered solid base of support among younger Black Americans. His rhetoric of self-reliance, pride, and independence spoke to a new generation of activists who broke away from some of the established tenets of the civil rights movement. This was a decisive time for the Black liberation struggle, as many eyes were on Williams, as noted in a quote from William Mahoney: “What happens [in Monroe] will determine the course taken in many other communities throughout the South” (265).
Tyson continues to reflect on Black Power and the Role of Violence in the Civil Rights Movement, showing how the harassment of demonstrators in Monroe pushed the question of violence to the forefront. The peaceful demonstrations staged by Williams were predictably met by harassment and violence, calling back to the idea that violence was “the last great bulwark” with which white Southerners defended their position in society (255). Bypassing a police force who had proven themselves unwilling to protect Black people, Williams organized to arm much of Monroe’s Black population with guns. Tyson notes that, though the police would not protect Black demonstrators for their own sake, they mobilized to prevent the eruption of large-scale violence that could endanger white people and harm Monroe’s reputation. The clashes in Monroe demonstrated the utility of armed self-reliance on a large scale. Had Williams and the other demonstrators not held the threat of armed violence over the heads of their enemies, Tyson suggests, they would likely have been attacked or even killed by outraged mobs. The encounter with the Stegalls once again highlights an abuse of power by an American government invested in preserving white supremacy. Despite acting in the “correct” manner by ensuring the Stegalls’ safety, Williams was charged with aggravated kidnapping and driven out of the country. The text suggests, therefore, that Williams’s views on violence were born out of the life-or-death realities of the Jim Crow South.
Williams’s activities during his exile years helped him further connect his philosophy to international politics, and Tyson examines this period as an example of The Effect of International Politics on Black Liberation. Williams aligned Black liberation with the liberation of oppressed peoples across the globe, adopting socialist and anti-war stances in a blended ideology that was reflected in the Black Power movement. Though the Black Power movement officially emerged in the years following the standoff in Monroe, Tyson once again emphasizes that it was in no way a new phenomenon. Noting that most historians characterize the movement as a “reversal” within the civil rights movement, Tyson instead describes it as a “renewal” of actions and ideals that were present from the very start of the Black liberation struggle. Tyson closes Radio Free Dixie with a final caution against accepting an idealized and sanitized history of the civil rights movement, implying that the story told about the civil rights movement is not just a matter of historical importance, but also determines how people think and act in the present day.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Timothy B. Tyson