30 pages • 1 hour read
Personification of Yang is the heart of “Saying Goodbye to Yang,” as narrator Jim contemplates aspects of the robot’s behavior. While Jim and Kyra outwardly consider Yang a machine, Jim grapples with the loss of Mika’s Big Brother as he tries to get him fixed and then, failing that, buries him. Jim recalls moments shared with Yang with varying emotion. When trying to introduce Yang to certain milestones he will share with Mika, in Yang’s aloofness, Jim is reminded that he is just a robot; when he takes Yang to a baseball game, he cheers because Jim cheers, not because he feels any excitement. Yang’s Fun Facts and caretaking are programmed into him, factory settings that nevertheless contribute to Jim’s family. Jim does slip into thinking of Yang as a real boy, especially when viewing the mementos he left behind, which magnifies his grief. Jim has lost not just a machine, but a robot on top of whom he grafted his emotions.
Jim is the first-person narrator of “Saying Goodbye to Yang,” thus readers experience his coming to terms with loss first-hand as he wrestles with how he is perceived. The perspective makes Jim the story’s key protagonist, the only one we have intimate knowledge of, so his journey drives the action. Jim is at times an unreliable narrator, as he deflects from his true feelings when focusing on the financial costs and scheduling burden associated with Yang’s demise. We also only see Yang through Jim’s perspective, and Jim keeps Yang at an emotional distance. It is difficult to understand the level of sentience Yang possesses from Jim’s limited knowledge. We also know when he is lying to others—like Kyra, George, or Russ—because he is self-aware and critical of himself. There are also moments of levity that punctuate the story that we are privy to because we are in Jim’s shoes: e.g., the virtual reality boxing match he is terrible at in Quick Fix, and his posturing with Russ to make it seem he has more technical savvy than he does add catharsis.
Jim’s narration is matter of fact when recounting the episode in his life that culminates in Yang’s funeral, digressing into humor or pathos at times. Yet nature imagery recurs throughout when Jim tries to explain his feelings. He is descriptive about the “red and orange leaves falling around” (13) him and Yang when they rake leaves, an anecdote that ends with Jim’s realization that he considered Yang a son at times. This is echoed in his description of the funeral, on a similarly bright, crisp fall day, the light “bringing out the ocher and amber of the season” (20). Jim describes feeling that time has slowed down after he was given Yang’s voice box, explaining, “The light of the setting sun had stretched across the wood floors of our home for what seemed an eternity” (18). Nature is a touchstone for Jim as he processes the denial and acceptance of his grief.
Often utilizing natural imagery, Jim resorts to metaphor when he has moments of emotional clarity, or to express and process his grief. When looking at the dead butterflies and moths on Yang’s windowsill, Jim notes they “look as though they’re ready to take flight” (19). This can be construed as a denial of death, as Jim searches for meaning in the collections Yang left behind; denial is a powerful stage of the grieving process.
When describing the aftermath of receiving Yang’s disembodied voice box, Jim remarks: “Sounds have become crisper as well, as though, until now, I’d been living with earplugs” (18). Death is a demarcation in Jim’s life, which will be irrevocably changed after losing Yang. Even though Yang is not a real person, Jim still experiences the loss deeply. Also, his encounters with Russ and George were made possible by Yang’s malfunction—people he considers different from himself, if not people to avoid. The inciting incident of Yang’s death makes Jim confront Russ’s bigotry and George’s sensitivity, things he turned a blind eye to beforehand. Ironically, his use of metaphor signals that Jim is seeing things more clearly after grappling with Yang’s—and his—mortality.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: