47 pages • 1 hour read
Late at night, Serebrakoff and Helena are dozing in armchairs in the dining room. Serebrakoff wakes up agitated, and Helena soothes him while rewrapping him in his shawl. Serebrakoff complains that he has intolerable pain in his legs, and he says he feels as though he’s suffocating. He fears that the pain is from rheumatism rather than the diagnosed gout, and he worries that the gout may have caused him to develop angina in his heart. Helena suggests that his difficulty with breathing is probably because this is the second night in a row he’s gone without proper sleep, and Serebrakoff lashes out at her in anger. He says she cannot understand the pains of old age and that he will soon relieve them all by dying. Helena cries and accuses him of torturing her, but he continues his tirade.
Sonia enters and chastises Serebrakoff for wasting Astroff’s time by calling for him and then refusing to see him. Serebrakoff calls Astroff a madman and then snaps at Sonia, who tells him she has too much work to do the next day and cannot indulge him by enduring his temper. Marina and Voitski arrive, and though Voitski offers to keep Serebrakoff company so that the women can go to bed—much to Serebrakoff’s horrified refusal—it is Marina who manages to coax Serebrakoff to bed with sympathy, memories of Sonia’s mother, and commiseration over their shared pains.
Helena and Voitski are left alone. They are both exhausted, and Helena declares that there is something wrong with the house. They are all at each other’s throats all the time and are destroying themselves with spite. She asks Voitski to help keep the peace, but he has spent the night drinking with Astroff and is intoxicated. He once again declares his love for Helena. He raves about his misery, his regret over his wasted years, and his feelings for her. Helena leaves in irritation, drained and angry beyond endurance at Voitski’s unwelcome advances. Alone, Voitski soliloquizes about the life he could have had if he’d married Helena in her youth when they first met. He laments that he spent the best years of his life working diligently to support the professor out of a sincere belief in the man’s genius, only to realize that the man is a fraud. Now, Voitski has nothing to show for all of his and Sonia’s hard work.
Astroff enters with Telegin, intoxicated and disheveled, pressing Telegin to play his guitar. He admires Helena’s beauty and indelicately talks of Voitski’s unrequited love for her. Voitski tells him that drinking makes him vulgar, and Astroff agrees, saying that he always feels magnanimous and powerful while intoxicated. Astroff and Telegin quickly leave when Sonia reappears, lest she be offended by Astroff’s state of undress. Sonia chides Voitski for drinking so much, and she complains that while he has been idle, she has been working herself to exhaustion. Voitski weeps and kisses her hands, telling her tenderly how much she resembles her mother. He then goes to bed, and Sonia approaches Astroff to beg him not to let her uncle drink so much.
Astroff is resolved to return home before morning, but Sonia insists on sharing some food with him before he leaves since he has not eaten all day. Astroff asks that he not be called to treat her father’s illness anymore since Serebrakoff doesn’t listen to him anyway. He’s comfortable speaking frankly with Sonia, confessing that he could not bear to live in their house because of how miserable all the members of her household are. He does acknowledge, however, that his own discontentment might be making him unduly harsh in his assessment.
Astroff says he is deeply unhappy because, although he likes life itself, he despises having to work himself to death in the countryside with no pleasant company among the peasants or upper classes. He has no hope that his life will ever improve. Sonia begs him not to drink so much anymore, and Astroff agrees. Sonia—who has been in love with Astroff for many years and suffers from his obliviousness to her feelings—asks him if there is really no one whom he loves, and he says there isn’t. After Astroff leaves, Sonia speaks in a monologue about how happy Astroff makes her, even though he has never said a word about his feelings for her. She knows that she isn’t beautiful, and she recalls overhearing neighbors call her likable and noble but unattractive.
Helena enters and asks Sonia how long she plans to be cold toward her since Helena would prefer to be friends. Sonia immediately embraces her and says that she has long desired to reconcile but was too ashamed to do so. They share a glass of wine, and Helena says that she knows Sonia resented her because she believed Helena married Serebrakoff for his money. However, she says she really believed she loved Serebrakoff when she married him, even though she now knows better. Helena admits that she’s deeply unhappy and would prefer a younger husband. Sonia confides her admiration of Astroff, and Helena agrees that he is handsome and intelligent. She says that his flaws are inevitable consequences of living in rural Russia under the crushing weight of decades of hardship and poverty. Helena then says she wishes Sonia happiness despite her futility and misery. Helena proposes that she play some music for them both, but Sonia goes to get permission from her father since music irritates him when he’s ill. Helena is happy at the prospect of playing music and releasing her emotions, but Sonia returns and tells her that Serebrakoff says that he doesn’t want to be disturbed by music.
Act II provides an insight into Serebrakoff and Helena’s routines at the estate. Immediately, Voitski and Marina’s complaints about the disruptions to the household routine and order are validated. Serebrakoff’s work habits, ailments, and bad temper keep the whole cast of characters awake in the middle of the night, even though many of them are deeply tired. Sonia is still trying to singlehandedly keep up with the estate’s grueling workload. The fact that she has been unable to get the hay cut and collected in time to prevent it from spoiling under the storm is tangible evidence of the negative effects of Serebrakoff’s disruptions. His arrival has cast an air of stagnation and rot over the estate—which brings up the theme of Despair Versus Work and Faith—and Voitski has been unable to avoid its influence. While Voitski usually helps Sonia with all the work, he has turned to napping during the day and drinking at night, which has not only left Sonia alone to manage the estate but also exacerbates Voitski’s despair.
Act II also builds on the theme of The Complexities of Interpersonal Relationships. Serebrakoff comes across as a pitiful but largely unsympathetic character in this act, which lays important groundwork for Voitski’s increasingly explosive resentment in the following section. Serebrakoff is suffering from his myriad health concerns. However, he is determined to make his discomfort everyone else’s problem and to take out his misery on those nearest to him. His unreasonable and unprovoked anger directed at Helena and Sonia when they are simply trying to help him—snapping at the former over her comparative youth and good health and the latter over medicine—shows his entitlement and unkindness. Serebrakoff’s reaction to pain and chronic illness is realistic.
The fact that he is so easily mollified by Marina’s heartfelt sympathy could be taken as a commentary on the expectations placed on ill and disabled family members. Still, his pain makes him ungenerous, which is represented by his refusal to allow Helena and Sonia to play music. He derails a potentially heartwarming moment of bonding between the two women and quells any chance of Helena rediscovering purpose or contentment through music. This action shows Serebrakoff’s mean-spirited and controlling attitude toward his family, which curbs their attempts at finding happiness.
The relationship between Sonia and Astroff is explored in more depth in this act, which also shows the complex relationships between the characters. It becomes clear through their interactions that Sonia has strong feelings for the doctor that are either unrealized or unrequited. This impression is confirmed by her candid soliloquy following Astroff’s departure and her following talk with Helena. The earnest sincerity and strength of her emotions, as well as her excited manner of sharing them, highlight Sonia’s youth and innocence. Helena takes on a maternal and friend-like role for Sonia in this section, showing the complexity of their relationship as well as the extent of the similarities between the two women. They are, after all, closer in age to each other than Helena is to Serebrakoff or Sonia is to Astroff.
The motif of alcohol reappears in this act too, most strikingly when Sonia persuades Astroff to give up drinking. This is a hopeful sign that Astroff might be able to overcome the despair and trauma caused by his profession, but this is later dashed alongside Sonia’s hopes that he will return her affections.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Anton Chekhov